Journal of Dialogue Systems Review Criteria

Manuscript title: ________________

Please rate this submission according to the following criteria.

OVERALL

Overall recommendation:
__ accept
__ accept with revisions
__ revise and resubmit
__ reject


CONTRIBUTION
How closely related is the topic of this paper to the
scope of the Journal of Dialogue Systems?
__ excellent
__ good
__ average
__ fair
__ poor


How significant is this paper's contribution to the
field; or, if a review article, how thorough is the
review of its subject?
__ excellent
__ good
__ average
__ fair
__ poor



METHODOLOGY

If a research article, how appropriate are the methods
described to the questions raised? Or, if a review
article, how appropriate to the topic are the methods
of selecting papers to review?
__ excellent
__ good
__ average
__ fair
__ poor


How clearly and accurately are mathematical,
experimental, and statistical techniques described? 
__ excellent
__ good
__ average
__ fair
__ poor

How strongly does the material presented in the paper
support the conclusions of its author(s)?
__ excellent
__ good
__ average
__ fair
__ poor



STYLE

How clearly is the paper organized overall?
__ excellent
__ good
__ average
__ fair
__ poor


How accurate and consistent are sentence structure,
spelling, and punctuation?
__ excellent
__ good
__ average
__ fair
__ poor


REFERENCES
How comprehensive is the references section?
__ excellent
__ good
__ average
__ fair
__ poor




GENERAL COMMENTS TO AUTHOR:



Please list below any specific corrections for the
author(s).


Please list additional works that should be discussed
or cited in the references section.